Safety and OSHA News

Opioids, pot and people who don’t work anymore due to pain

Has the number of jobless men exploded because they take opioids for pain relief? What if they used pot instead? 

About one in eight U.S. men ages 25 to 54 don’t have a job and aren’t looking for one, notes a recent column in The Washington Post. These seven million men aren’t part of the officially unemployed – those counted in the official U.S. unemployment rate.

In the mid-1960s, only 1 in 29 prime-age men were so-called dropouts.

The Post column by Robert J. Samuelson looks at why this number of jobless men has ballooned. The Great Recession? Maybe, but there’s been recovery from that. The number of incarcerated men? Maybe, but they’re not counted until they leave prison and then can’t find a job.

Samuelson discounts those two theories because a survey shows only 15% of dropouts said they weren’t employed because they couldn’t find work.

On the other hand, 40% of those surveyed said their disabilities prevented them from working full-time for jobs for which they were qualified.

And nearly half of male dropouts report taking pain pills every day.

Male drop-outs say they’re less happy, more sad and more stressed.

Case in point: Greg Vialpando. Readers of Safety News Alert might recognize that name because he fought to have his workers’ comp insurance cover medical marijuana in New Mexico, and won.

Vialpando turned up in the news again just days before the Post column in a New York Times article about whether workers’ comp will pay for medical marijuana to counter chronic pain.

Before he used marijuana to counter his pain, Vialpando tells the Times he “withdrew from his family and friends, preferring to spend time by himself, watching television … he lost interest in food,” when he was on opioid painkillers.

Now, while using medical marijuana, Vialpando has gained weight, enjoys talking again and engages in hobbies. His wife reports his personality has returned to what it was before he was injured. “I feel like I’ve gotten my husband back,” she said.

There will soon be 28 medical marijuana states, some just recently added to the list because voters approved medicinal pot in the recent election. But only five of those states (Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan and New Mexico) require workers’ comp insurers to pay for medical pot.

New Mexico had considered a bill to exempt insurers from paying for medical marijuana. But after Vialpando and another patient testified how marijuana “let them escape years of stupor caused by powerful prescription narcotic drugs” (opioids), state legislators killed the bill.

Meanwhile, a study shows painkiller prescriptions decreased in states where medical marijuana is legal.

Are doctors prescribing pot more often to treat chronic pain instead of narcotics like opioids? Maybe. The California Workers’ Compensation Institute suggests in a report that medical professionals who can’t prescribe pain medications, such as chiropractors, naturopaths and registered nurses, may recommend their patients try marijuana.

However, little data exists to compare the effects of marijuana on a person’s judgment with that of other painkillers like opioids.

Thus, we don’t know what type of work a person prescribed marijuana for their chronic pain might be able to do safely.

But given what Vialpando and others who have experienced both opioids and pot for chronic pain management have to say, it sounds like it’s worth looking into.

The alternative may be a growing percentage of workers who drop out, not because they can’t find a job, but because they’re taking pain pills every day and they rather stay home and watch TV.

What do you think? Should there be more research into medical marijuana as a pain-management alternative? Share your thoughts in the comments.

Print Friendly

Subscribe Today

Get the latest and greatest safety news and insights delivered to your inbox.


  1. Aaron Tipton says:

    As for the comment of ” The alternative may be a growing percentage of workers who drop out, not because they can’t find a job, but because they’re taking pain pills every day and they rather stay home and watch TV.” is straight bull. I only work because my disability payments from the military can’t cover my bills. By working I further increase the chances of paralysis starting in my lower extremities, and deal with the extreme pain caused by an injury from an IED explosion. I take pain pills that could make Mic Jagger pass out yet here I am. Not all of us “users” are on this medication by choice. Just to get up and around I take what I need to in order to function. Yes, Id much rather not have to drag my ass in to a low paying safety job just to make my condition worse, however, I do because I have no other choice. As for Pot being used for pain management, I’m all for it. The only issue I would have is the over abundance of former hippies using his or her stoner days as a comparison for how it would or wouldn’t help. As safety professionals, we need to take a concerted effort to see what the effects are on this in the work place in the interest of safety. I say this two hours after taking opiate pain pills and knowing this too has effects on everything I do at work. Either way, If you are going to write and article on this or any other issue, make sure it is unbiased across the board. I was thinking of signing up for this site, but am strongly reconsidering it now with this blanket statement regarding disabled individuals being labeled as lazy drug addicts.
    Get a clue next time and shame on you.

    • Safety Manager says:

      Tipton, I didn’t read near as much as you did into this one sentence from the article “The alternative may be a growing percentage of workers who drop out, not because they can’t find a job, but because they’re taking pain pills every day and they rather stay home and watch TV.”
      The author states that the alternative MAY be a growing percentage of workers who drop out….

      And I in no way took any part of the article to be labeling disabled individuals as lazy drug addicts.

      I thought the article was very informative and unbiased.

Speak Your Mind