SafetyNewsAlert.comNew study sheds light on which employees become whistleblowers » Safety News Alert

New study sheds light on which employees become whistleblowers

July 24, 2012 by Fred Hosier
Posted in: In this week's e-newsletter, Latest News & Views, OSHA news, whistleblower, Workers' attitudes about safety


How do you stop whistleblowers from taking their concerns directly to OSHA?

A new study shows whistleblowers only go outside their organization to report problems when they are forced to by fear, inaction or both.

The Ethics Resource Center report says only 2% of employees go solely outside to report problems.

Others may eventually go outside their companies about wrongdoing but only after they’ve tried the inside route.

So how do you stop whistleblowers from taking their concerns elsewhere? Respond quickly and effectively when employees report misconduct.

The researchers suggest executives reconsider their characterizations of whistleblowers as disloyal, self-serving employees. Instead, companies might consider how they motivate and assure workers that bringing problems to the attention of managers is effective.

Some other findings from the report:

  • 65% of workers who witnessed rules violations in 2011 reported them
  • 56% of those who reported misconduct took their reports to someone they know and trust inside the company, such as a direct supervisor
  • only about 5% would be motivated to report outside the company for a monetary reward
  • at companies showing no signs of economic recovery, 63% of those who witnessed wrongdoing reported it. That numbers goes up to 77% at companies where recovery is more evident.

Monetary incentives are more likely to motivate workers who’ve suffered pay cuts. Thirteen percent of workers whose salaries declined in the last two years said they would report wrongdoing to the government only if there was a chance for substantial financial reward.

The report recommends companies take steps to get potential whistleblowers to bring their concerns to someone within their companies.

Companies can encourage reporting by clearly defining misconduct and how to report it, demonstrating that reporting has an impact, standing behind employees who come forward and acknowledging those who report.

Rewards can be as simple as a handwritten note of thanks or recognition of the report during the employee’s annual performance review.

But if that performance review is several months off, don’t wait. Have the employee’s supervisor thank the person for their report.

What do you think about this research? How do you encourage workers to report safety problems to you? Let us know in the comments below.

Share

The Safety Insights You Need
Get the latest safety news, trends, and insights - delivered weekly.


Join over 334,000 safety pros:

Privacy policy

Tags: , , ,


  • VS

    We have an anonymous whistleblower program at my company. I’ve had two experiences with it, funny, it’s anonymous but in both cases I knew who it was and both were directly stemming from disciplinary action. The first involved a worker terminated for excessive absences and tardiness. He claimed that we were singling him out. The next day HR shows up wanting to see our attendance records and documentation. We had it all and he wasn’t singled out. The next one was even worse. A foreman called me to a site because one of his workers was in the portacan for over an hour. I talk to the guy who claimed he was sick with a personal illness. I sent him home and advised him to go see his doctor. The next day HR shows up because an anonymous phone call that we’re timing people in the portacans and suspending people for taking too long in them.
    Ridiculous yes, but I understand why companies have to investigate this stuff nowadays. So my experience with whistle blowers hasn’t been positive.

  • alecfinn

    We’ve never had a whistle blower because we investigate every complaint. What we found was the folk who were trying to cause trouble backed down. That was when they realized all complaints were investigated and reviewed in the Environment o Care Committee (used to be the Safety Committee) monthly and all complaints were kept on record so false reports were dealt with.

    However even if a staff or other person reports something even it they have a track record of bad reports we investigated. Similar to a abduction report sent to the FBI (As a Psychiatric Center and we have had patients call authorities to report they were abducted by Aliens from another world and we were still contacted and investigated right to a visit from a police agency).

    You never know unless you look if there is a real problem or something else….Sometimes you have to deal with the something else………


advertisement



advertisement

Recent Popular Articles