SafetyNewsAlert.com1 company, 8 years, 9 amputations » Safety News Alert

1 company, 8 years, 9 amputations

September 29, 2010 by Fred Hosier
Posted in: amputation, In this week's e-newsletter, Injuries, Latest News & Views, lockout/tagout, What do you think?


Imagine this: Nine workers at one company suffer various types of amputations, ranging from part of a finger to most of an arm, yet the company has avoided paying large fines in many of the cases.

That’s the result of an investigation by the Los Angeles Times into Bimbo Bakery locations throughout California between 2003 and this year.

And it appears recent large fines against the company may not have been enough to stop the amputations.

The company was already facing $230,000 in fines after inspections at four plants found equipment lacking proper guarding.

Then, in January, an employee at one of the plants that was inspected lost part of his finger. Investigators later found machines didn’t have proper guards.

Cal/OSHA has issued another $123,000 in fines after that incident.

Inspectors found supervisors may not have been encouraging workers to stop machinery to clear dough that becomes stuck. In many of the incidents, workers put their fingers in machines that were still running.

Bimbo officials have agreed to take steps to improve safety, but they are contesting the fines.

Bimbo Bakeries makes a number of well-known brands of breads, tortillas and pastries, including Tia Rosa and Entenmann’s.

Why hasn’t Bimbo paid large fines? Many were dismissed or significantly reduced on technicalities by Cal/OSHA’s appeals board.

Example: Employee Rosa Frias lost most of her arm in 2003 when it was sucked into a running bread machine. Cal/OSHA fined Bimbo $21,750.

But the case was dismissed after an administrative law judge on the appeals board said the agency could not prove its inspector had permission to enter the factory. The inspector had retired and wasn’t available to testify.

What do you think about this situation? Let us know in the Comments Box below.

Share

The Safety Insights You Need
Get the latest safety news, trends, and insights - delivered weekly.


Join over 334,000 safety pros:

Privacy policy

Tags: , , ,


  • John S

    Bimbo Bakeries USA

    Fast Facts

    Industry…Food Manufacturer

    Headquarters
    Fort Worth, Texas

    Known for its trusted brand names in fresh
    baked foods, Bimbo Bakeries USA produces the
    finest breads, rolls, buns, tortillas, chips, snack
    cakes, cookies, donuts, cakes and pastries
    under a variety of popular brands. Look them up online.

    Want to hit them hard…boycott their products

    Revenues
    $4 billion
    Number of Employees
    5,000

    Do the math. Each employee is worth approximately $800,000.00 each to amass an annual turnover of $4 billion.

    The fines certainly are no deterrent. The cash flow surpasses any penalty. It could be the cost of an incident is built in and connections…They certainly are with Washington Lobbyists.

  • http://orionquality.com Jack Kinnemann

    9 amputations in 8 years. And they are still operating! someone has their hand in a politicians pocket!

  • Pingback: Health and Safety Source :: Health and Safety Blog ::  Health and Safety News from Across the Web

  • Paleto

    The amount of a fine that OSHA is ‘restricted’ to levying on a company is outrageous. They are meant as a deterrent, but larger companies look at it like a cost of doing business….”IF” they get caught.

    These companies only look at the costs to implement and maintain a Safety, as opposed to the long term benefits of the program: Higher productivity, lower medical costs, employee satisfaction, less lost work days, a good public image, etc…

    It’s sad to say that there are companies like this, it is a fact that everyone is aware of, but making an example out of A BUNCH of companies might just be the answer….if the administrative law judges will allow it.

  • http://safetynewsalert.com Ken Williams

    Dave B sounds correct! Amputations for “unguarded” machinery are a big deal everywhere else. I feel for the employees, but, I fall back on that old adage, that if I know it’s not safe, don’t do it!
    (Supervisors may not have been encouraging workers to stop machinery to clear dough that becomes stuck). Don’t these employees know they can call OSHA if someone is directing them to do something dangerous? All of mine do!
    Doc

  • Dave B

    Smells like Bimbo Bakery management has strong financial connections to a politician or other person of significant authority…


advertisement



advertisement

Recent Popular Articles